Yes, THIS IS THEATER as one of the characters professes mid-way through Ken Ludwig’s Moon Over Buffalo at Waukesha Civic Theatre. But with a name like Moon Over Buffalo, I expected something of a modern rom-com. Spell check wants to turn rom-com into coatroom…which might apply since the closet plays a role in the play. But it is far more insidious that a standard rom-com. Yes there is romance and long term love and misunderstood love and canoodling…so it goes down the theatrical rabbit hole to a farce. A grand farce at that!
We are in fact in Buffalo New York with a traveling theater company who are presenting two plays in repertory, Cyrano de Bergerac and Private Lives. And our main set is a green room or staging area in a rather tired theater except for the stunning fainting couch! Our two principals are a long time married couple, a bit past their prime as actors, who have played romantic and dramatic roles opposite each other for a long long time…apparently very successfully, until recently. And they are waiting for their next big break which is surely just around the corner. But here we are in Buffalo.
And it is the early 1950s so not are they only fighting the movies for attention, but the fledgling television industry as well. A media type that they seem to abhor, but I wonder.

We meet our intrepid company on the ramparts as Tony Davis over exclaims as George Day in a rehearsal of Cyrano…with some fairly lackluster support from his supporting cast. But Davis has just the needed comedic chops here to bluster and extol and overdo it from his ill-fitting costume and misaligned over the top Cyrano nose. But this is just a glimpse of what Davis will be called upon to do. Beyond the comedic lines and situations he needs to perform any number of pratfalls and drunken stumbles and an amazing sword duel with his wife Charlotte. I repeat, an amazing sword duel with his wife Charlotte.

Yes, sweet Charlotte. Played by Tanya Tranberg as a grand dame of theater. Proper, prim, a bit stodgy at times, but impulsive too and a great fencer! She is in love with the theater and with the future she sees for herself and George in the movies. But Tranberg’s Charlotte is also a romantic in love with George but not necessarily willing to overlook all of his transgressions…finally ready to be wooed by Richard, their high powered show-biz attorney. And Glenn Villa is a delightful self-centered and smarmy big city ego yet love sick beyond his own comprehension Richard.

And Rosalind, George and Charlotte’s daughter comes to Buffalo for a visit. It isn’t a chance visit, she wants to introduce her parents to her new fiance, Howard. But there is some serious sub-context here. Rosalind was raised in the theater and trained in the theater and was part of her parent’s company until she decided she wanted a normal life. Lisa Bransdorf’s Rosalind is clearly a smart level headed and determined young woman. And despite her parents disappointment she is determined to follow her own vision. And then there is Paul. He is part of the repertory company, smart, young, and accomplished in the theater and has the same drive as George and Charlotte. And Rosalind’s former fiance. Hmmm. Marty Alivo plays a smart and driven theater maven ready to put the show on at all costs…with maybe just a little disbelief that Rosalind dismissed him and the company and a fair amount of bitterness. And then there is Rosalind’s new beau, Howard, a professional TV weatherman but played as a timid and starstruck eme’ Esquivel, who has no idea what he’s about to experience. But when no one ‘appears’ to be home, he begs off and leaves setting up some of the most hilarious mistaken identity scenes this side of Shakespeare.

And Hannah Franzen rounds out the cast within the play as Eileen, the theater company’s ingenue. Franzen plays the role to a T, with a boisterous, frantic pace that Eileen’s place in the story demands. You’ll see why, below. And the last character here is quite a character as played by Tom Aldridge. ETHEL! Ethel is an elderly woman, Rosalind’s grandmother and Charlotte’s mother. Aldridge plays it dumb, he plays it clever, and he plays it elderly at times…and makes the most of Ethel’s reluctance to wear her hearing aids when they would be the most helpful and vice versa.

Well, there are the characters and here is a brief synopsis without giving away the jokes and gags. Much of the story relies on making fun of the theater and theater practices…and particularly the character of Cyrano. It also has fun with romantic love on a number of levels and stereotypes of love in the media. And of course, it relies a great deal on the mis-identification of characters, particularly poor Howard who is totally lost here. So here goes…we can seen George’s Romeo to Charlotte’s Juliet, but who would expect his turn as a Lothario with Eileen. That dalliance results in her pregnancy and turmoil ensues. I don’t want to give much more away because that’s where the humor resides. But I will say that there are four doors on stage, one closet, one exterior door, and two that appear to go to dressing rooms or the stage. A far amount of time is humorously spent running in and out of these doors looking for one character or another. Keystone Kops it is! But, but, but: Frank Capra makes an ‘appearance’ looking for stars for his new film. I couldn’t leave that out, it’s important (well if you know who Frank Capra is).
But never fear! True love wins out in the end.
One last statement: the true magic here is how directors DJ Castine and his brother Cole Castine have taken the disparate characters, many plots and subplots, and myriad loose ends and woven them all together into an amazing whole clothe.

Moon Over Buffalo runs at The Waukesha Civic Theatre on Main Street in Waukesha from now through September 27, 2026. Ticket information here!
Extra Credit Reading: The Playbill












