First Stage Presents Peter Pan And Wendy With NO Strings Attached

Certainly since the original appearance of J.M. Barrie’s play, Peter Pan in 1904, and his later novel, Peter And Wendy of 1911, there has been a certain magic felt across the land by the young of heart in every age group. Being a man of a certain age, my first experience with the magic was a televised broadcast of the Broadway presentation starring Mary Martin. Yes, it did make a lasting impression on me and I was excited to see how the artists and young actors of First Stage would bring that magic to life once again.

Working from an adaptation by Doug Rand, First Stage Artistic Director Jeff Frank directs his own theatre for young audiences adaptation. Frank has rediscovered and reveled in all of the magic found in Peter Pan. All of the magic! The whole story is here, from Wendy and Nana and the great window in the nursery, to a flying boy in Peter Pan, to the Lost Boys, to Captain Hook and Smee, and the crocodile and the clock….and Tinker Bell of course (or Tinkerbell? I have found it both ways but for a real fairy I’d have named her Tinkerbelle).

Todd Denning (front left), Marko Van Slyke (front right), and cast in Peter Pan and Wendy. First Stage, 2026. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

First Stage presentations for young audiences can often be hard to describe because they are anchored by a number of adult actors but feature two rotating casts of young actors. Peter Pan And Wendy is no different, featuring a Shadow Cast and Light Cast of actors. So if you are interested in seeing a particular youngster on stage, make sure you know which cast they are in and select a date and time appropriately.

First Stage presentations at the Todd Wehr Theater in the Marcus Performing Arts Center are often big cast musicals…Peter Pan And Wendy isn’t a musical but it is a BIG cast. But don’t be fooled about not being a musical. Peter Pan And Wendy is still a rowdy boisterous bit of theater that kept all of the young audience completely entranced. So much so that their laughter and gasps and sidebars sometimes interfered with me hearing the dialogue on stage…but that’s one of the highlights of attending plays at First Stage: seeing the reactions of the youngsters in the audience. Rest assured that this play satisfies!

Simon Phillips (top right) and cast in Peter Pan and Wendy. First Stage, 2026. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

Now, on to the adult actors. Todd Denning is a regular at First Stage but you probably remember seeing him most recently as the Ghost of Christmas Present at the Milwaukee Rep. For Peter Pan And Wendy he handles two roles…first the loving but maybe just a bit ditzy father of Wendy and John and Michael Darling. Denning’s befuddlement around tying his tie in the opening scenes and leading the way to the drawing room while wondering if the Darlings have a drawing room in the finale. But more importantly is his portrayal of…dah dah dum dum…CAPTAIN HOOK! Oh Denning can be as sinister as need be and leads his pirates by dint of force and personality only to instantly cower at the sound of a ticking clock and the possibility of being attacked by THE crocodile. Tori Watson is Mrs. Darling, and is the perfect elegant and doting mother at first but turns equally fretful when describing her first encounter with Peter Pan…and Watson easily takes on the mourning mother when her children go missing and finally the restored mother who eagerly adopts the Lost Boys and instantly works to help a clearly conflicted Peter Pan.

(L to R) David Flores, J.T. Backes, and Sawyer Felkey in Peter Pan and Wendy. First Stage, 2026. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

And our pirates, Tim Linn, Sherrick Robinson, David Flores, and J.T. Backes are jolly rogers all. A great team dedicated to protecting their captain and swashbuckling to the nines! David Flores as Smee is a bit of comic relief that suits Flores instinctively and suits the pirates presence just as well.

The two most important characters of course are those in the title of the play, Peter Pan and Wendy. Frank’s adaptation perfectly exhibits Peter’s determination to remain young and have fun which of course appeals to Wendy’s sense of adventure. But there is a bit more to their relationship than that. Wendy senses it but Peter, like many young men, doesn’t really know what is happening and doesn’t respond as Wendy expects. From my note above, there are two casts of young actors. I saw the Shadow Cast and Marko Van Slyke as Peter Pan and Niamh Mayne as Wendy were amazing. Overall the blocking and choreography for such a large cast (there are nine lost boys plus Peter, Wendy, and her two brothers) and a moving set was fluid and riveting and you just can’t seem to take it all in at once, but somehow you do.

SPOILER ALERT: We saved Tinker Bell

But there is more magic here than just the story of Peter Pan. There is First Stage magic. As always First Stage lighting designers and set designers put together these amazing designs that seem so simple at first but are so deeply ingrained in the story telling that they are almost a character in their own right. And for Peter Pan And Wendy it was no different…as we had the nursery and its great window and Neverland and the pirate ship and and and. So thank you to Sarah Hunt-Frank, Nicki Kulas, Jason Fassi, Josh Schmidt (sound designer), and Jason Orlenko (costume designer)!

And let’s talk about Nicki Kulas again. First Stage productions often feature mythical creatures or natural creatures that can’t necessarily be portrayed on stage, so they use PUPPETS: magical, phantastical, puppets! In this case, a bit of a shaggy sheepdog, the children’s nursemaid Nana, the ever lurking and very creepy crocodile, and two iterations of Tinker Bell. One little lacy bit of green light that flits around the action and a bit larger version that at times lands on a shoulder or chair back and has the semblance of a fairy rather than just a bit of flashing light. How they all work is in the next paragraph.

Marko Van Slyke in Peter Pan and Wendy. First Stage, 2026. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

And let’s not overlook that Peter Pan can fly, and Peter teaches Wendy, John, and Michael how to fly. The primary key to being able to participate in all of the other adventures. And fly they do but without wires. Inspired by Japanese theater, Frank has employed the use of koken in Peter Pan And Wendy. Koken are black clad characters who appear on stage unnoticed by the actors. In this adaptation, the koken lift the young actors portraying Peter and Wendy and let them ‘fly’. They also work the puppets representing Tinker Bell, Nana, and the crocodile. And yes you notice them but you don’t…I can’t quite explain the effect, but it quite simply works.

Ooooh. I almost forgot. There is always a brief talk back after the curtain when young theater goers can ask a question of the cast. My favorite this time was some young man who wanted to know where they found the crocodile. After some giggles, a cast member described the puppet and how it was made by the puppet master!

Beyond the main story, all of the subplots are here. The desire for eternal youth, the desire for freedom from authority, the desire for family and structure, and the desire for a sense of purpose all prevail.

Peter Pan And Wendy continues through March 22, 2006 at the Todd Wehr Theater in the Marcus Performing Arts Center. Run time is about 75 minutes plus a 15 minute intermission. Recommended for families with young people ages 6-14 and magical dreamers of all ages.

More information and tickets can be found here.

Extra Credit Reading: Enrichment Guide

The Pigeon Gets A Big Time Holiday Extravaganza AND We Get One Too! A WORLD PREMIERE

Over the past several years I have probably reviewed more than a dozen big stage musicals presented by First Stage, but I have never experienced an audience who were so fully engaged in the action…answering questions asked by the characters of one another…shouting or groaning when there was a controversy…or swaying and waving along with the cast in the big production numbers. It was incredibly heartwarming to feel the intensity and excitement from these young theatergoers. And once again, I was at a loss, since I didn’t have the backstory on the Pigeon, but I obviously am not in on the ‘joke’.

Are you ready for a song?

YES! This is after all a big stage musical and the music flows joyfully and easily tells the story rather than just illustrating it, in remarkable solos, duets, and ensemble pieces that just resonate through the Todd Weir Theater. AND I forgot to mention this is a WORLD PREMIERE. Oh I guess it’s in the title.

This is a holiday extravaganza but isn’t just about holidays. There are I think, three stories here. Pigeon feels lost and a bit outside the community and searches for meaning in life and his place in the world. Elephant and Piggie extol the virtues of BFF (best friends forever), and then things start to get squirrelly, with a whole cast of squirrels representing community engagement and social involvement. All incredibly brought together with the thought of a holiday extravaganza.

Kailey Azure Green in The Pigeon Gets A Big Time Holiday Extravaganza! First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

Let’s start with the star of our show, The Pigeon! The Pigeon is played by Kailey Azure Green, not in costume, but as the vehicle for a pigeon puppet. Our pigeon rests on Green’s forearm while one hand activates the bill and the other the wings of the pigeon. Although deftly handling the puppeteering chores, the most fun is watching Green themself as they voice the pigeon and sing the parts and emphatically displays the pigeons emotions in their body language, voice, and the expressions of their face. A lot of fun and joy in their actions.

Now, none of the other actors are dressed in costumes or represent their characters in puppet form despite portraying any number of animals…because their feelings and actions are just so peoplely.

James Carrington and Rachael Zientek in The Pigeon Gets A Big Time Holiday Extravaganza! First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

And our best friends? They are James Carrington as Elephant Gerald and Rachel Zientek as Piggie. Carrington and Zientek are obviously fan favorites since they got a spontaneous round of applause on their first appearance on stage. I have seen Carrington in a number of First Stage productions now and he embodies the spirit of what First Stage is all about. And he and Zientek have a very very engaging chemistry on stage…this is the third time they’ve worked together reprising their roles of Gerald and Piggie. And they have their own little drama as they are sure they have picked out precisely the perfect gift for their friend until they are overcome with a dread that their friend might not like it. Songs and drama ensue…and a little humor as well. They are simply delightful to watch!

So that covers the three adult actors in our big holiday extravaganza, and here’s where things start to get squirrelly! All of the other roles are filled by young people!

Adyson Ries (front) and cast in The Pigeon Gets A Big Time Holiday Extravaganza! First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

And it seems we have a squirrel for every occasion. Our main team is planning the extravaganza…a lot of excitement and a lot of energy…and great plans get planned and great plans go awry…until In-Between Squirrel sparks an idea and the day is saved. Some highlights include the trio of Catchy Holiday Squirrels who sing a festive holiday song and appear to reprise it a number of times during the play. It becomes an ear worm for the Pigeon but is a delight for those of us in the audience who hear snippets of traditional holiday songs stolen or satirized in the song…until smack in the face…there it is: a pigeon in a pear tree! And watch for Defining Squirrel, a real fan favorite with the young audience, who enters the stage with a placard for ‘bigger’ words and their definition. The trope itself is funny on its face but there is bigger humor later in the play that I won’t spoil by revealing it here.

But everyone comes together in the end and a holiday extravaganza is enjoyed by all and I guarantee that you will enjoy it too. And Santa’s sleigh and an unnamed reindeer make cameo appearances.

Cast in The Pigeon Gets A Big Time Holiday Extravaganza! First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

This is a challenging musical to stage because of the number of actors involved and the number of songs involved but director Michelle LoRicco has done an incredible job of bringing it all together. And as always the sets and lighting is first rate First Stage quality which stands on a par with any theater group in town.

I didn’t mention the young actors because First Stage always uses two casts of young actors. I saw the Hotdog cast and they stole my hearts…but from my experience, the Cookie cast will do the same. But keep in mind that there are two casts. So if you are hoping to see a particular young performer check the listings for which day their cast will perform when buying tickets!

But I do have one question that perplexes my aging brain. So if one of our young readers could fill me in. Why did the pigeon walk to the North Pole? I mean, one cool thing about being a pigeon is being able to fly.

The Pigeon Gets A Big Time Holiday Extravaganza runs about 65 minutes plus a short intermission and is being presented at the Todd Wehr Theater in the Marcus Performing Arts Center through December 28, 2025.

Recommended for families with young people ages 4-14 and festive celebrators of all ages

Ticket information and further details can be found here:

And extra credit readings: the Playbill and the Enrichment Guide

First Stage Presents The World Premiere Of: Esperanza Rising.

Esperanza Rising is a world premiere commissioned by First Stage. It is adapted for the stage by Alvaro Saar Rios with original music by Dinorah Marquez and is based on the book by Pam Munoz Ryan. This is the most personal and poignant play that First Stage has presented this season and maybe in the period that I have been enjoying their plays.

First Stage is a tremendous youth theater opportunity for both audience members and young aspiring actors. When they play at the Todd Wehr theater they usually present large scale musicals with wonderful choreography and of course, music, with large ensembles of adult and young actors, and dynamic presentations around characters well known to their young audience.

(left to right) Ashley Marie Rodriguez, Laura Crotte, Miranda Rose, and Aria Martinez in ESPERANZA RISING. First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

Esperanza Rising is a bit different. Dinorah Marquez has provided some very memorable songs and music that celebrates Mexican culture and family. These songs are sometimes sung by the ensemble and sometimes by individual characters in the play. But here they support the storytelling instead of being a major force in the play. And that adds to the personal. And the storytelling is key.

And a quick reminder. When First Stage presents these larger plays at the Todd Wehr, the core cast of adults remains constant, but the young actors rotate via alternating casts. So I saw the Hope cast on Sunday May 4th, 2025. So if you are hoping to see a particular young actor, check the link below to see which cast (Hope or Dream) they are a part of and when they are performing.

The play is set in the 1930s and begins in Mexico where Esperanza is growing up on her family’s farm. Her father is a very wealthy land owner and the 1930s were a turbulent time and after a pair of family tragedies, Esperanza’s mother decides to move to California along with some of the staff from their farm. They settle in a migrant farm camp and for the first time in her life Esperanza confronts hardship and poverty and the need to work. It is a growing experience for a young girl who is about to turn 13 when we meet her. And this is a very special story about the importance of family and community.

Laura Crotte (left) and David Flores in ESPERANZA RISING. First Stage,
Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

There are five adult roles around Esperanza, but three adult actors. Ashley Marie Rodriguez is Mama. A confident and strong woman who so obviously loves her family but makes a tough decision in the face of adversity and wishes nothing more than a better future for her daughter. Laura Crotte plays both Abuelita and Hortensia. As Abuelita she is the doting grandmother to Esperanza who lovingly teaches her to knit. She too has to make some tough decisions. And Crotte smoothly transitions to Hortensia, a practical and emphatic woman who befriends Esperanza’s family in California. And David Flores is Papa and Alfonso. First a caring and doting father who always gives his daughter a doll for her birthday and does so again for her 13th. But this one takes on more meaning and Esperanza cherishes it. Flores is also simply solid and practical as Alfonso as he moves his family to California and helps Mama and Esperanza reach there as well.

Now, there are two storytellers per the cast list. They are the narrators who fill in the back story and history of the period as well as fill in the relationships of the characters and at times tell us what the characters are thinking. They also get to play a number of small parts: the ‘bad’ guys in Mexico in silly silly mustaches, the immigration agent in California, and a police officer. The storyteller roles are played by young actors from the alternating casts. On Sunday they were played by Lucia Harris and Eleanor Dysart with flair and grace but a bit of comedic posturing when on stage as the ‘bad’ guys, and a certain bit of menace as the border agent or police officer.

Miranda Rose (left) and Thomas Alberto Bastardo (right) in ESPERANZA
RISING. First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

There are three other young person roles. Miguel who is Alfonso’s son, childhood friend of Esperanza, and shall we say, love interest. Thomas Alberto Bastardo makes a suave and thoughtful Miguel, an optimistic youth and like his father, someone who can get things done. And Isabel, a young girl at the migrant farm who is paired with Esperanza to baby sit Isabel’s younger siblings. Aria Martinez is a delight with her curious questions and disbelief that Esperanza needs to be taught to change a diaper. They end up being very close in the end. And Marta, an activist and union organizer on the farm. Erin E. Frailing presents a very determined and focused Marta but… The storytellers are eager to march and chant her slogans.

There is some Spanish spoken at times but you don’t need to be bi-lingual to understand the meaning…it is apparent from the situation. And First Stage recommends Esperanza rising for young people 7 to 17 and theater lovers of all ages, I highly recommend this to adult theater goers even if you don’t have a child in tow. This story and these situations are pure drama and I think anyone interested in theater will enjoy this. And despite the era, the topics are very contemporary in their feel. First Stage has done an incredible job and again, I will say, this is a very poignant and rewarding presentation.

Cast in ESPERANZA RISING. First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

Esperanza Rising will continue from now until May 18, 2025 at the Todd Wehr Theater in Marcus Performing Arts Center. The play runs about 75 minutes with a short intermission.

Additional information and tickets can be found here.

And extra credit reading: The Playbill

Ashley Marie Rodriguez (left) and Isabel Scardino (right) in ESPERANZA
RISING. First Stage, 2025. Photo by Paul Ruffolo.

And the final word from Isabel: “My Heart Is Dancing”.